Keep It Real: Building Brand Authenticity through eCommerce Returns
Rebecca Fox

June 5, 2024

Nowadays, customers are looking for relatable, authentic brands that offer more than just high-quality products and competitive pricing. Returns offer an amazing chance to show your brand authenticity and build customer loyalty. 

Understanding Brand Authenticity in eCommerce

Brand authenticity goes beyond having a sleek logo or catchy tagline. It’s about staying true to your values, delivering on your promises, and building genuine connections with your customers.

Customers need to trust that your store will provide them with quality products, accurate information, and a good shopping experience. 

Your customers want to feel like they’re interacting with real people, not just a faceless corporation. They want to believe your brand stands for something beyond just selling products – 90% of customers think it’s important for a brand they buy from to be authentic.

Now here’s the trick – when your brand authenticity extends to your returns process, you take customer trust to the next level.

The Impact of Brand Authenticity on Returns

How customers perceive your brand can play a big part in your return rates. When customers trust your brand and feel confident in their purchases, they’re less likely to return items out of uncertainty or dissatisfaction.

Authentic brands tend to have lower return rates and better returns management processes. Here’s why:

Customer Satisfaction and Trust

While returns have the potential to be a stressful experience for customers, an authentic and transparent returns process can ease their anxiety and build trust in your brand. 

When customers experience a friendly, helpful, and convenient returns process, they’re likely to be happier with their overall buying experience and feel more positive about your brand. In contrast, a complicated, confusing, or unreliable returns process can damage your brand image and lead to negative customer experiences.

Offering no-hassle returns and easy-to-follow return policies, you demonstrate your commitment to customer satisfaction and build trust with your customers. 

If your customers believe that your brand cares about their needs and values, chances are they’ll come back to buy again and recommend your brand to others.

Brand Differentiation and Brand Identity

Authenticity is a powerful differentiator in the competitive world of eCommerce. When customers feel like they’re buying from a brand that shares their values and principles, they’re more likely to choose that brand over less authentic competitors. In fact, 77% of customers are more likely to buy from a more expensive, authentic brand than an inauthentic competitor.

Returns play a critical role in the overall brand experience, giving customers a glimpse into how your brand operates and treating them with respect and consideration.

Taking a customer-centric approach to returns helps build a strong, memorable brand identity that differentiates you from other brands.

Long-Term Customer Retention and Revenue Growth

Ultimately, a well-executed returns process can lead to long-term customer retention, revenue growth, and stronger brand loyalty. Conversely, 66% of customers will stop buying from a company whose values don’t align with theirs.

When customers have a positive experience during the returns process, they’re more likely to make future purchases and recommend your brand to others. This can lead to additional revenue and positive word of mouth, helping to establish your brand as a reputable and authentic choice for customers. 

Brand authenticity is becoming increasingly important to customers. By focusing on creating an authentic and customer-centric returns process, you can build trust, strengthen customer loyalty, and create a positive brand experience. This can lead to lasting customer relationships, increased sales, and long-term revenue growth for your business.

5 Strategies for Building Brand Authenticity Through Returns

Now that you understand the importance of authenticity, let’s dive into some practical strategies for building it in your eCommerce store through the returns process:

1. Make Your Returns Policy Reflect Your Brand Values

Make sure that your return policy aligns with what your brand stands for and the experience you want to offer your customers. 

Whether you pride yourself on outstanding customer service or eco-friendly practices, make sure your returns policy reinforces these values. For example, if sustainability is a core value, consider offering eco-friendly return options or donating returned items to charity instead of restocking them. 

Transparency is key here; clearly outline what qualifies for a return, your return window timeframe, and any associated fees, so customers know exactly what to expect.

2. Use Returns as an Opportunity for Authentic Communication

Every return is a chance to connect with your customers on a deeper level. Share real stories of returns experiences from your customers and highlight how you handled them with integrity and empathy. 70% of customers say they want brands to connect with them on a more personal level.

You can also use your website, blog, and social media to share authentic stories that resonate with your target customers and help them connect to your brand. Whether it’s a heartfelt customer testimonial or a behind-the-scenes look at your returns process, these stories can help humanize your brand and build trust and loyalty among your customers.

Additionally, make sure to make all your post-purchase communications as authentic as possible, from approving the return to sending the refund. Give the customer all the information they need to track their return and know it’ll get taken care of.

3. Stand Out by Being Authentic

In a crowded eCommerce landscape, authenticity can be your secret weapon for standing out from the competition. This is especially true when it comes to handling returns. Look for opportunities to showcase what makes your brand unique, even in your returns process. 

Whether it’s offering a self-service return portal, free returns, eco-friendly return options, or bonus store credit, these authentic touches leave a lasting impression and set you apart from the competition.

4. Build Trust through Transparency

Handling returns with integrity, empathy, and professionalism can turn a potentially negative experience into an opportunity to strengthen customer relationships and reinforce your brand’s authenticity. 

A transparent and customer-centric returns experience shows your customers that you value their business and are committed to making their shopping experience positive. Keep customers updated throughout the returns process, including any delays or hiccups that may occur. Set clear expectations and then meet those expectations, to create a transparent and open experience.

8 out of 10 customers say that it is powerful for brands to illustrate empathy for their in-the-moment needs, provide insightful recommendations, demonstrate brand values through action, and remember previous actions taken with the brand.

5. Measure and Evaluate Brand Authenticity

Make sure to keep an eye on how being authentic impacts your eCommerce business. Keep track of key metrics such as customer satisfaction, repeat purchase rate, and return rate to see if your efforts are paying off.

Use feedback from customers and insights from analytics tools to keep improving your brand’s approach to authenticity.

Use Your Returns Process to Build Brand Authenticity

The bottom line is, customers care about authenticity, and your returns process is an important opportunity to showcase your brand’s values and build trust. 

So be real, be transparent, and align your returns process with your brand, and you’ll be able to create a great customer experience that drives loyalty and sales.

Related Posts
How E-commerce Returns Impact Your Accounting

How E-commerce Returns Impact Your Accounting

One of the main pain points for e-commerce stores is offering returns to customers while maintaining the business’s financial health and accounting processes. Having a clear understanding of how returns impact your accounting is crucial for keeping your records...

The Power of Smart Supply Chains in Returns Management

The Power of Smart Supply Chains in Returns Management

Smart logistics in return management is vital for modern supply chains, directly impacting customer satisfaction and operational costs. Businesses can achieve major improvements in efficiency and customer satisfaction by integrating AI, demand forecasting, route...

Streamline your return process and ensure a great post-purchase experience for your customers.